Grey background with purple hexagons

Beyond Good Intentions in International Development

The field of international development is full of stories of good intentions gone wrong. Many of these shortcomings have stemmed from cultural misunderstandings.

Overall, there has been a shift in understanding that good intentions are not enough. Good intentions on the part of volunteers, program directors and even government agencies are not enough to sustain development and bring tangible results to the intended recipients.

One group that is routinely the recipient of good intentions is people with disabilities.

The international development community has voiced a commitment to disability inclusion through documents at the UN level.

But what does this mean in practice? What work is still left to be done? What does the future of international development in light of these commitments?

Let’s talk about it.

The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities

The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was adopted in December 2006 at the United Nations headquarters with the intention of being an opportunity to develop policies and structures that ensure that persons with disabilities are mainstreamed within the United Nations system. The United Nations systems is a leader in international development activities. Disability inclusion at this level of international development has great potential to bring enormous global benefits.

The CRPD is intended as both a human rights and a development instrument which explains how all categories of rights apply to people with disabilities, and identifies practical measures to create development programs that are inclusive of, and accessible to, people with disabilities.

It is built on a broad categorization of disability and reaffirms that all people with all types of disabilities must enjoy all human rights and fundamental freedoms. It clarifies and qualifies how all categories of rights apply to persons with disabilities and identifies areas where adaptations must be made for persons with disabilities to effectively exercise their rights and highlights areas where their rights have been violated, and where protection of rights must be reinforced.

That all sounds great, right?

Current Realities

Knowledge by itself doesn’t mean acceptance. Awareness campaigns are commonplace today but they really aren’t leading to acceptance and greater accessibility. They result in a greater sense of celebrating good intentions by participants. The heart of disability issues isn’t about awareness that disabled people exist! It’s about having access to the world in ways that work for a variety of people.

People need access to all areas of community life in terms of both the built environment and its information and communications systems. Communities thrive when their members are all able to contribute to that community; its growth and function.

All community entities need to take responsibility for ensuring equal access to their respective spheres by people regardless of disability status. If access is denied to any community member the community’s life as a whole is affected. However, these denials are so commonplace that the negative effect on the community is rarely noticed.

Development documents, initiatives, and programs are meant to aid in creating this equal access. And if you look solely at the words in the documents and the existence of ‘disability inclusion’ it seems like it’s a well-integrated topic. However, in many countries, a disability and development gap is growing.

Unless systematically planned for and included in policies and programs, people with disabilities are at increased risk of being adversely affected in times of humanitarian disaster and emergency and generally left behind in terms of any development improvement metric.

Many initiatives regarding disability inclusion are still at the level of well-intentioned statements and broadly defined policy objectives. These efforts must be translated into effective implementation and followed-up carefully by solid monitoring and assessment mechanisms if true global inclusion of people with disabilities is to succeed.

Looking to the Future

Increased access to disability inclusive data and statistics will increase the ability to ensure that programs are targeting the areas of greatest need and inclusion is actually occurring. The development and dissemination of this data will help in the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities at the local, national and international levels.

The sharing of knowledge including good practices, lessons learned by experts is a critical component along with the involvement of organizations of persons with disabilities on national and international levels. The participation of these organizations is an essential part of effectively guiding the development agenda towards integrating and including people with disabilities into all future and ongoing activities.

Lessons can be learned from the mainstreaming of issues such as gender and HIV/AIDS into development agendas. The development of new guidance and informational tools can lead to significant positive gains.

Ultimately, new and innovative thinking and collaboration are required to see the ideals of the Convention implemented in ways that bring the maximum benefit to people with disabilities and society.

We need to be intentional about valuing the lives of people with disabilities in so many ways. Our dialogue about disability needs to be explicit actions rather than simply words on a document no matter how official the document.

Add Your Voice

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.